Remembering Fabien Barthez and The Gamble of Possession Play in Goalkeeping

David De Gea said farewell to Old Trafford this weekend after twelve years at the club.

Over the past year, the Spaniard has come in for some public criticism due to a perceived inability to play out from the back with the ball. United have been here before, and as they close in on a deal for Andre Onana of Inter Milan, it could be a case of the grass being greener on the other side.

With the most appearances and most clean sheets of any goalkeeper in the club’s history, De Gea goes down as a legend without question, and there are still plenty who believe that as a shot-stopper there are few if any equals in the game; and within that number, there is an additional number who believe that is the primary quality required for a goalkeeper.

Stability is often one of the most undervalued traits in football because people like entertainment and by and large a footballing public has short memories. When Lisandro Martinez and Raphael Varane were both fit, De Gea’s ability on the ball rarely needed to be called into question. Still, United as a club have been one of the pioneers of changing up the goalkeeper position; their signing of Harry Gregg was engineered with the purpose of pushing the play up the pitch, whilst their acquisition of Alex Stepney was made with the knowledge of his calm and assurance on the ball.

Peter Schmeichel on the other hand was a revolution all by himself; all things in one, and arguably the greatest of all-time. It was a struggle to replace him, even though United did sign the best shot-stopper in the league at the time in Mark Bosnich. Famously, that did not work out, and even more famously, neither did Massimo Taibi. Sir Alex Ferguson looked for a successor.

Fabien Barthez’s time at Manchester United was marked by his unique ability to play with the ball at his feet. His proficiency in distributing the ball from the back, coupled with his shot-stopping abilities, made him a charismatic figure on the pitch. However, it became apparent that the risk involved in having a goalkeeper who gambles in possession may not always yield favourable results.

When Fabien Barthez joined Manchester United in 2000, he arrived with an impressive resume, having won the FIFA World Cup with France in 1998. United fans were optimistic about his ability to elevate the team’s play, and he didn’t disappoint. Barthez quickly established himself as a shot-stopper par excellence, displaying exceptional reflexes and composure under pressure. However, it was his eagerness to initiate attacking moves by playing the ball out from the back that truly set him apart.

Barthez’s penchant for playing with the ball at his feet brought a new dimension to the game. He frequently ventured outside his penalty area, acting almost as an extra outfield player. This approach not only caught opponents off guard but also entertained spectators who marveled at the audacity of a goalkeeper participating in outfield play. Barthez’s confident distribution and his ability to find long-range passes became a trademark of his game.

However, there were times when Barthez’s eagerness to play with the ball became a liability for Manchester United. His calculated risks sometimes backfired, leading to costly mistakes. Opposition teams soon recognized his inclination to venture forward and began exploiting the space left behind. Counterattacks became a greater threat, as Barthez’s forays from the goal allowed opposing strikers to have an easier path to score.

In a game at Highbury, Barthez made two basic errors which contributed to Thierry Henry getting a brace; and who could forget the chance taken with a raised arm hoping for an offside against Paolo Di Canio in the FA Cup?

The position of goalkeeper at Manchester United is the single-most scrutinised in world football; the gambles taken by Barthez started to undermine the stability of the team.

It is crucial to acknowledge that playing with the ball at one’s feet has become more commonplace among goalkeepers in recent years. Nonetheless, the key is striking the right balance between calculated risks and defensive stability. While Barthez’s style brought excitement, it also exposed the team to unnecessary risks, jeopardised vital points in the league table, and caused elimination from the cup.

There is genuine excitement for Ohana’s potential arrival but the compilations posted online that show him taking risks, whilst exciting when successful, have the capability to induce great stress through the support in a manner much more prominent than anything De Gea did.

In the end, what matters most for a goalkeeper is their ability to make crucial saves and provide a solid foundation for the team’s defence. While possession play can enhance a team’s attacking potential, it should never come at the expense of defensive stability. The primary role of a goalkeeper is to prevent goals, and any attempts to gamble in possession should be carefully weighed against this objective.

There is a modern narrative in football which has apparently diluted the need for a goalkeeper who can save shots as a preference to passing the ball. If it goes sour at United, the one thing that has never changed is the media attention on the country’s biggest club, and De Gea might well be remembered and respected more fondly with hindsight.

Fabien Barthez’s time at Manchester United highlighted the dual nature of possession play in goalkeeping. While his ability to play with the ball at his feet added a unique dimension to the team’s style, the risks associated with this approach ultimately proved costly. Sometimes, the safer option of a goalkeeper who prioritizes defensive reliability trumps the gamble of possession play.

It is safe to say that Onana is not the current best goalkeeper in the world, but, in spite of the above caution, that is not to say that his arrival would not be welcomed. He has a well-established relationship with Erik Ten Hag and that counts for something considerable, potentially eliminating some of the risk.

Leave a Reply

Previous Story

The Boys Who Became The Busby Babes

Next Story

Exclusive : Ratcliffe Sees Himself As ‘Custodian’ Of Manchester United’s ‘Best Interests’

Latest from Columnists

Stand By Ten Hag

Two wins, three losses, negative goal difference, and 13th in the league. That was the state